Jay's Original Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create own pizza.
$7.89
White Pizza
Shelby's white sauce olive oil, garlic, house spices, fresh spinach, banana peppers, tomatoes, provolone, and mozzarella cheese.
$13.95
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza
Minimum preparation time 45 minutes.
$7.59
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
$1.59
Thursday Special
Wings Thursday Special
$0.75
Friday Specials
Fish Sandwich Friday Special
On hoagie bun.
$11.95
Fish Fries Sandwich Friday Special
On hoagie bun.
$14.95
Soups
Homemade Wedding Soup
$4.95
Chili Soup
$4.95
Soup of The Day
Call and ask for soup of the day!
$4.95
Appetizers
Tater Tots
Tossed in any wing sauce served with homemade ranch or blue cheese.
$7.95
Fried Ravioli
Served with marinara sauce.
$7.95
Homemade Stuffed Hot Sausage
Banana Peppers topped with marinara, provolone, and mozzarella cheese.
$7.95
Chicken Tenders
Tossed in your favorite wings sauce & served with homemade ranch or blue cheese .
$7.95
Cheesy Bread
Jay's original glazed with olive oil, hose spices, and garlic butter parm sauce.
$9.95
Beer Battered Onion Rings
$7.95
Double Hand Breaded Cheese Sticks
With sauce
$7.95
Buffalo Balls Tossed
In buffalo wing sauce w/ a side of ranch or blue cheese.
$7.95
Shelby's Style Seasoned Whole Wings
With your choice of sauce or dry rub.
$12.95
Shelby's Style Seasoned Half Wings
With your choice of sauce or dry rub.
$7.95
Garlic Balls Fresh Jay's Dough Fried
Topped with garlic butter parm.
$7.95
Salads
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Plain or buffalo crispy chicken in our homemade buffalo sauce, shredded cheddar, mozzarella, hard-boiled eggs, croutons, tomatoes, and onions, served over a bed of fresh greens and topped with seasoned fries or tater
$13.95
Shelby's Chicken Salad
Sautéed peppers, onions, tomatoes, provolone cheese, tater tots, hard-boiled eggs, croutons, and black olives served over a bed of fresh greens topped with seasoned fries or tater
$13.95
Shelby's Steak Salad
Sautéed peppers, onions, tomatoes, provolone cheese, tater tots, hard-boiled eggs, croutons, and black olives served over a bed of fresh greens topped with seasoned fries or tater
$13.95
Chef Salad
Ham, salami, turkey, pepperoni, hard-boiled eggs, tomatoes, banana peppers, provolone cheese, croutons, and black olives served on a bed of fresh greens
$13.95
House Salad
Pepper rings, shredded cheddar, mozzarella, provolone, hard-boiled eggs, tomatoes, croutons, onions, green peppers, and black olives served over a bed of fresh greens and served with a house italian or house ranch dressing ...
$10.95
Sides
Fries
$4.95
Onion Rings
$4.95
Tost
$4.95
Salad
$5.95
Strombolis & Calzones
Vegetarian Calzone
Spinach, mushrooms, provolone cheese, onion, green pepper and tomato.
$14.95
Stromboli
Baked ham, provolone cheese, and pepperoni.
$14.95
Steak Calzone
Steak, provolone cheese, mushrooms and onions.
$14.95
Sausage Calzone
Sausage Provolone cheese and green peppers.
$14.95
Hoagies & Sandwiches
Hot Sausage Hoagie
Shelby's tangy, yet sweet italian sausage, with peppers and onions in marinara sauce topped with provolone and mozzarella cheese.
$8.95
Shelby's Philly Style New York Strip Hoagie
Choice of fresh sliced in-house new york strip steak or grilled chicken, sauteed onions & bell peppers, mushrooms, provolone and mozzarella.
$8.95
Shelby's Philly Style Grilled Chicken Hoagie
Choice of fresh sliced in-house new york strip steak or grilled chicken, sauteed onions & bell peppers, mushrooms, provolone and mozzarella.
$8.95
Turkey Bacon Ranch Sandwich
Fresh sliced turkey breast, bacon, provolone, house made ranch dressing with lettuce and tomato.
$8.95
Club
Turkey, bacon, ham, provolone, lettuce, and tomato.
$8.95
Shelby's Italian Hoagie
Ham, capicola, salami, sandwich pepperoni, provolone, and mozzarella cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, onions, and our own garlic Italian dressing.
$8.95
Stuffed Banana Pepper Hoagie
Fresh hot stuffed italian sausage banana peppers topped with marinara and provolone cheese.
$8.95
Meatball Hoagie
Homemade meatballs topped with marinara sauce and cheese.
$8.95
Veggie Hoagie
Bell peppers, lack olives, banana peppers, spinach, mushrooms, provolone cheese topped with lettuce , tomato ,and garlic Italian or ranch dressing.
$8.95
Chicken Parm Hoagie
Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
$8.95
Buffalo Chicken Hoagie
Crispy chicken tossed in homemade buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomato, and cheddar topped with homemade ranch or blue cheese.
$8.95
Shelby's Ruben
Shelby's Ruben
Fresh sliced corned beef , grilled and topped with swiss cheese, sauerkraut & house made dressing , and served on marble rye. Served with fries.
$11.95
Rolls
Pepperoni Roll
Fresh Jays pizza dough stuffed with pepperoni, mozzarella, parmesan, and provolone cheese saved with pizza sauce for dipping. Topped with garlic butter parm sauce.(Ask For It Plain)
$6.95
Italian Mega Meat Roll
Fresh jay's pizza dough stuffed with ham, cappicolla salami, sandwich pepperoni, provolone and mozzarella, cheese. Served with garlic dressing or marinara for dipping..
$11.95
Desserts
Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies
$1.00
Ice Cream Sandwich
$4.95
Michele's Cannon Balls
Jay's pizza dough is rolled in cinnamon and sugar and topped with powdered sugar and chocolate sauce for dipping.
$6.95
Jay's Pizza
Support local businesses while treating your tastebuds! Try some of the top pizzas in McDonald and find a new favorite. Jay's Pizza remains one of the most popular in McDonald. Give them a try and see what makes them such a favorite. For a true flavor of the city, try some of McDonald's top dishes. See what all the fuss is about with these local favorites. Don't miss the chance to try the popular Fish Sandwich Friday Special. It's a classic for a reason. Don't forget to add fries to your order. See why this delicious item is a local favorite. This reliable restaurant has been a Slice partner for 2 years. You can count on them providing something tasty. Curbside pickup at Jay's Pizza makes things easy. Place an order, and it'll be ready for you to pick up at your convenience. Keep costs down by taking adavantage of deals offered by Jay's Pizza. Nothing beats the feeling of making your dollars stretch further. Jay's Pizza accepts credit cards. That makes it easy to get your pizza sooner.
Full Hours